Sunday 10 January 2016

11th January 2016

The Internet in Education

From the five potential problems listed on pp 234-236 in Roblyer, which may have the most impact on your classroom and students and why?  How will you address these concerns in your lesson planning in your assignment and in the future? 

Another issue related to internet use - particularly in schools - is the restricted nature of internet access.  We have seen why this would be considered necessary, but it also stifles the ability of both teachers and students to access the resources they need.  What are you able to access at your school or intitution - or not?  Does this work?  What does this mean for an educational institution where many students have internet capable smart phones?  Does this mean restrictions should be relaxed and better supervision should be utilised? 

Roblyer & Doering (2014) list the following 5 common Internet problems:

1.  Accessing sites with appropriate materials
2.  Safety and privacy issues
3.  Fraud on the Internet
4.  Viruses and hacking
5.  Copyright and plagiarism   (pp. 234-236)

Number 5 copyright and plagiarism has the most impact on students in my section (adult English language learners), particularly in Cert III English for Further Study and Cert IV English for Academic Purposes courses where students are required to write academic essays.  There is a cultural aspect to this as it seems that in some cultures plagiarism and breaching copyright laws is more acceptable than it is in Australia.  We have had students with post-graduate degrees from other countries blatantly plagiarsing the work of others in academic essays, sometimes even copying and pasting text from an Internet site (word for word) and passing if off as their own.  We have developed a unit of work in each of these courses explaining exactly what plagiarism is and how to reference correctly in the Harvard style.  To say we enforce and reinforce this is an understatement!  As most of these students plan to enter university in Australia it is essential that they learn this.  Most seem to be quite savvy about the other 4 issues, however students often express their concerns over their children accessing inappropriate material on the Internet so we introduce them to filtering software such as Net Nanny to use at home (I installed this on my son's laptop when he was about 15 - he wasn't happy about it but it was effective).

Up until about 2 years ago all social networking sites and Youtube were blocked in my institution (TAFE).  However it became apparent that social network sites such as Facebook are the way most students receive and send information as well as communicate with each other.  It was also realised what a valuable teaching tool Youtube is, so these sites were "unblocked", TAFE now advertises its courses on Facebook and each Institute has its own Facebook page which students are invited to join.  There are still blocks on certain sites, I don't know what the criteria is but the firewall kicks in at odd times. for example the Oz Lotteries site, however we are now able to access the majority of websites that we need to.  Of course there is the issue of students connecting to social media to chat to their friends on their smart devices during lesson time,  this is another classroom management issue for teachers to deal with.



5 comments:

  1. Hi Alison,
    Although I work at a different end of the spectrum to yourself I have found similar issues being played out with students in Stage 2 and Stage 3.
    Plagiarism is a big concern - students sometimes seem to quite honestly not understand the ramifications, or think that the teacher 'won't know' (although when they leave the hyperlinks there its a pretty big clue!).
    I wonder also to what extent teachers are talking the talk, but not necessarily walking the walk. Robyler and Doering (2014) certainly noted web activities such as downloading and utilsing whole lesson plans with minimal, if any, change or acknowledgement. I found a blog from Purrington, 2014, noting teacher trends of plagiarising and also found some interesting work from the National Council of Teachers of English from 2008 on this issue.

    ReplyDelete
  2. My blog is bethsblog2015.wikispaces.com.au - please view for further information and details from these sources!

    ReplyDelete
  3. Hi Alison,

    I enjoyed reading your post and I agree, YouTube can be a very powerful resource! I have been working with younger grades and have yet to experience much of the social media push that I am sure is prevalent in all schools today. I am however always looking for ways to communicate effectively with students and parents in order to keep everyone involved. Email has proved efficient enough for distributing information however I find that there is generally very little feedback as opposed to other forms of communication.

    I can only imagine what it must be like trying to manage a classroom with those kind of chat capabilities, however treating the access as a privilege may generally help students stay responsible with their use.

    Jess

    ReplyDelete
  4. Hi Alison,

    Thanks for sharing your professional experiences on your blog, particularly from TAFE which provides more interesting insights about Classroom Technologies in different contexts.

    I'd like to ask your take on how long it took TAFE to unblock Youtube and if there were any staff discussions about it; I'm curious what the decision making processes are like. Youtube is supremely underrated as a teaching resource! I'd like to know if you also had input or if the teachers were consulted in that decision. Schools and educational institutions I find can be a bit slow to change or adapt to change, it takes a while for things to be taken up or changed from what I've experienced.

    Finally, how effective were the units of work in each subject in reducing the incidence of plagiarism within the subject?

    Phil

    ReplyDelete
  5. Hi Alison, I really enjoyed reading your posts. I am teaching in the Middle East, and similar to you, most things are blocked at my school, either by the government or the school board. This includes YouTube, so I understand your initial frustration! I have found TeacherTube is a good alternative although some of the videos are quite poor quality. But like Phil mentioned above, I am curious as to what the decision making process was like in altering your schools decision to unblock YouTube?

    ReplyDelete